Convertible Loan Notes vs Advance Subscription Agreements

James Church

WRITTEN BY

James Church

Author, Investable Entrepreneur

James is an award-winning business advisor and best-selling author. His clients have raised over £250m in early-stage funding. 

Sometimes you need money before you are ready to price a full round. An investor wants in now, or you need runway to reach the milestone that will set your valuation. In the UK, two documents do most of this work: the convertible loan note and the advance subscription agreement.

Both let investors put money in today and receive shares later. But they work differently, and for UK founders raising from angels the choice can decide whether investors get SEIS or EIS tax relief.

What is a convertible loan note?

A convertible loan note (CLN) is a loan from an investor to your company that is designed to turn into shares later, rather than be repaid in cash.

Typical terms include:

  • Interest, often a few per cent a year, which usually converts into shares along with the loan.
  • A maturity date, often 12 to 24 months away, when the loan must convert or be repaid.
  • Conversion at the next qualifying round, usually at a discount to the new investors’ price.
  • A valuation cap, which limits the price at which the loan converts.

Because it is debt, a CLN gives the investor more protection. If the company is sold or wound up before conversion, the noteholder may be repaid before shareholders.

What is an advance subscription agreement?

An advance subscription agreement (ASA) is an agreement under which an investor pays money now in return for shares that will be issued in the future. It is not a loan. The investor cannot get the money back, and there is no interest.

The shares are issued at your next priced round, often at a discount or subject to a valuation cap. If no round happens by the longstop date, the shares are issued anyway, usually at a pre-agreed valuation.

The SEIS and EIS problem with convertible loan notes

This is the key difference for most UK startups. SEIS and EIS shares must be subscribed for in cash and fully paid when issued. Shares issued on converting a loan are issued in return for a debt, not new cash, so they do not qualify. Osborne Clarke’s summary of HMRC’s guidance makes the same point.

An ASA can qualify, as long as it meets HMRC’s conditions. According to HMRC’s Venture Capital Schemes Manual, the agreement must:

  • have a longstop date, which HMRC generally expects to be no more than six months after the agreement is signed
  • not allow the money to be refunded in any circumstances
  • not be varied, cancelled or assigned
  • carry no interest
  • be for new money to fund the company’s trade, not a disguised loan or a way of converting existing debt.

If your investors rely on SEIS or EIS relief, an ASA is almost always the right choice. Read SEIS Explained: What It Means for Your Startup Raise for the wider rules.

Convertible loan note vs advance subscription agreement at a glance

FeatureConvertible loan noteAdvance subscription agreement
Legal natureDebtPrepayment for shares
InterestUsually yesNo
Repayable?Can be, if not convertedNever
Typical time to conversion12 to 24 monthsUp to 6 months for SEIS/EIS
Discount and valuation capCommonCommon
SEIS/EIS eligibleNoYes, if HMRC conditions are met
Typical investorsVCs, corporates, overseas investorsUK angels and syndicates

How conversion works: a worked example

Say an investor puts in £100,000 under an ASA with a 20% discount and a £3 million pre-money valuation cap. Four months later, you raise a seed round at £2.00 per share, a £5 million pre-money valuation.

  • With the discount: the investor’s price is £1.60 (£2.00 less 20%), giving 62,500 shares.
  • With the cap: the cap price is £1.20 (£2.00 × £3m ÷ £5m), giving 83,333 shares.

Most agreements give the investor whichever is better, so here they receive 83,333 shares. A seed investor putting in the same £100,000 would receive 50,000.

The same maths applies to a CLN, with any interest added to the amount that converts. Always model both outcomes on your cap table before you sign. Our guide, What Is a Cap Table? A Simple Guide for Founders, shows how.

When to use each one

Choose an advance subscription agreement if:

  • your investors are UK angels who want SEIS or EIS relief
  • you expect to raise a priced round within about six months
  • you want a simple document with no debt on your balance sheet.

Choose a convertible loan note if:

  • your investors don’t need SEIS or EIS, for example VC funds, corporates or overseas investors
  • your next round may be more than six months away
  • the investor wants the protection of being a creditor.

Some founders use both: an ASA for angels claiming relief, and a CLN for institutional investors in the same bridge.

Key terms to negotiate

  1. Discount. Typically 10% to 25%. A higher discount rewards earlier risk but dilutes you more.
  2. Valuation cap. A low cap can give early investors a large stake if your round prices well above it.
  3. Qualifying round. Define the minimum size of round that triggers conversion, so a tiny raise doesn’t convert everything.
  4. Longstop or maturity. For an ASA, set the longstop within HMRC’s expectations and agree the valuation that applies if no round happens.
  5. Exit terms. Agree what happens if the company is sold before conversion.
  6. Interest (CLN only). Agree whether interest is paid or converts into shares.

Common mistakes

  • Using a CLN for SEIS investors. It costs them their relief.
  • Adding a refund clause to an ASA. Any right to get money back can break SEIS and EIS eligibility.
  • Setting a longstop beyond six months. This risks HMRC treating the ASA as not qualifying.
  • Stacking too many convertibles. Several notes and ASAs with different caps can make your next round complicated and dilutive.
  • Skipping advance assurance. If you plan to use SEIS or EIS, apply before you take the money. See SEIS Advance Assurance: How to Apply and Why Investors Ask for It.

Frequently asked questions

What is a convertible loan note?

A loan to a company that converts into shares at a future funding round, usually at a discount.

Is an advance subscription agreement a loan?

No. It is a payment for future shares. It cannot be repaid and carries no interest.

Can convertible loan notes qualify for SEIS or EIS?

No. Shares issued on converting debt do not meet the cash subscription rules.

What happens if no funding round happens before the ASA longstop date?

The shares are issued anyway, usually at the valuation set out in the agreement.

Final thoughts

Convertible loan notes and advance subscription agreements both help you raise quickly without agreeing a valuation today. For most UK founders raising from angels, the ASA wins because it protects SEIS and EIS relief. The CLN is still useful for investors who don’t need the tax relief or for longer bridges.

Whichever you choose, investors still need a clear story about what the money will achieve. Our seed funding pitch deck services help founders get there. You can also read our guide to the stages of startup funding.

Want help getting investment-ready?
Let's talk about how I can help you raise.

About the Author

James Church is an award-winning UK startup advisor, fundraising strategist, and author of Investable Entrepreneur. He has helped founders raise more than £250 million in investment by improving investor readiness, refining fundraising strategies, and developing compelling pitch decks.

Through Investable Entrepreneur, James works with entrepreneurs to create investor presentations that communicate value clearly, strengthen fundraising confidence, and improve investment outcomes through practical, real-world expertise.